How the Second World war lives on with the Chinese and Japanese island disputes

Davey Meelker

While Germany is fighting for a united Europe, the conflict between China and Japan is escalating. “What has that got to do with each other”? you could say. Well, both events originated from the same period of history but both countries handled the aftermath in a completely different way.

During the Second World War both Germany and Japan were conquering their regions (Japan had already started colonizing China) and both countries were defeated in 1945. However, both countries have a completely different way of coping with their war history. When we asked Japanese people about the war they try to change the subject. Japanese people, especially the younger ones, don’t want to talk about the war that led to the biggest military defeat in the Japanese history. In Germany people, again especially the younger ones, also don’t to talk about the war that often. The difference is that Germans born after the war are overloaded with facts about the war and the terrible role Germany played in it. In Japan this is unthinkable.

It is interesting to notice how both countries are coping with their defeats. In Germany a huge and impressive Holocaust museum is established, commemorating the many Jews and others who died in this terrible genocide. In Tokyo a shrine is erected were class-A war criminals are enshrined and the attached museum tells a hugely favorable story about Japan during the war. The Japanese cabinet minister Jin Matsubara even visited the shrine to pay his respect. What caused this difference between the two countries?

The Japanese are not only friendly and extremely polite people, they are also very proud. Furthermore, in Japanese culture ‘losing face’ seems to be the worst thing thinkable. As a result, the proud Japanese find it is hard to admit that the many atrocities the Japanese committed were just wrong. In the Yushukan museum in Tokyo it is even stressed that although Japan lost the war, through the decolonization process the Japanese ideals were still implemented. They claim a moral victory. Some of the older generation still has trouble admitting their military loss. An old man told us that “it is still shame that we didn’t persist in the war.” This something you will never hear in Germany. The museum in Tokyo confirms the old man’s view and stressed that after the explosions of the two atomic bombs the Japanese spirits and confidence had never been so high. Only out of great loyalty to the emperor who surrendered did they put their guns down.

After the war the victors divided Germany, while Japan was briefly occupied by the US (until 1952). This left the Japanese culture and policies intact, while in Germany a strict anti Nazi government was established.

When Japan lost the war they were apologetic towards the US, who soon became their closest ally. Nevertheless, most of the atrocities were committed against Asians. At that time other Asian countries were politically and economically weak and had not much leverage to force Japan to apologize. Japan, therefore, could easily get away with it.

Germany murdered mostly Westerners and therefore could not get away with it. Germany was conquered by various western countries (including the Soviet Union) who became the next world powers. They made the German atrocities against their fellow Westerner extremely clear: Germany was responsible for one of the darkest pages of Europe’s modern history and had to cope with the feeling of guilt. As a consequence, children learn about the role of Germany during the war from a very young age, memorials are erected and lots of apologizes are made. Compensation is paid to survivors and relatives of the murdered.

The consequences of different ways of coping with the war are shocking. First of all, there is the aspect of humanity. By recognizing the atrocities and apologizing for it, it helps victims to deal with past. Many still feel that their suffering is unrecognized (read more here) Furthermore, it is a warning for humankind and a lesson to let this never happen again. Other than that, there is much more.

Because modern Germany distanced itself completely for what happened and sincerely apologized for what the country did, the country soon established good relationships and economical ties with the region. Now Germany is not only a respected member of the EU, it even has the leadership role in a united Europe. It is a great motor of the European economy.

Meanwhile, the Japanese government doesn’t recognize most of the atrocities and never distanced itself from it. Consequently, this subject obstructs relation with other Asians countries, especially South Korea and China, up till this day.

This resulted in fierce reactions of other countries in region. For example, recently South Korea and Japan were verbally fighting over disputed islands after the South Korean president Lee visited the island which Japan claims to be part of their territory.

The fact that Japan never admitted Nanjing Massacre in 1937 still bothers China and is a major source of conflict. China succeeded in mobilizing others to block the Japanese entrance to the security council in 2005. In the same year massive protests broke out throughout China because of the publication of a new school textbook that downplays the Japanese crimes during the war. The sympathy of the region was overwhelming on the Chinese side.

Now the disputed island situation, over which both countries claim ownership, is escalating. According to China some islands were taken by Japan when it colonized Taiwan in 1894 and were historically part of China. Therefore they should be returned after the Japanese defeat in 1945. In late 2010 the Japanese coastguard arrested the captain and the crew of ship entering the waters close to the island, resulting in diplomatic crisis and a wave of anti-Japanese demonstrations. Recently, fourteen Chinese people were arrested by the Japanese coast guards when they were entering the disputed islands. As a reaction Japanese activists planted the Japanese flag on the disputed islands, causing the biggest anti-Japanese demonstrations since 2005 in China. Now, both countries’ coastguards are circling around the islands in a cold war. In the media the possibilities of real war are even discussed.

Germany and Japan: two different ways in coping with the war. Not only in terms of humanity is it important to condemn the atrocities, but by doing this it paved the way for Germany to be the motor of a modern united Europe. Meanwhile Japan will face a difficult future. After the war Japan didn’t invest in relationships with the region, because Japan established huge economic growth and didn’t need allies in the region since they had great ties with the West. Now, the influence of its ally America is declining worldwide and the global power balance is shifting. China is growing fast economically and in august 2010 it replaced Japan as the largest economy of Asia. Japan could ignore the region for a long time, but it is getting more difficult everyday.

Japan and Germany: both aggressors in a cruel war, but with a different history, a different culture, a different policy and a different future.

Tags: , , , ,

2 responses to “How the Second World war lives on with the Chinese and Japanese island disputes”

  1. Lucas says :

    But with trade you also have to take into account for how large couienrts are in another way. A lot if inter-state trade in the US, whioch is not considered exports would be for say germany. Germany traded with Italy, its exports. Texas trades with new York, its not. Small countries like Hong Kong have such high trade as a percent of GDP because they have to. They cant possibly specialize efficently enough aras of production, where a large country like the US has many comparative advantages. So if you look at exports per capita for the entire EU with non-EU nations, which is a more accurate comparison with the US, you find that the US exports more per capita then the EU per capita. Though we also import more too.

  2. Jorrit says :

    Insightful, smart, informative. Thanks Davey. Groeten

Share your thoughts on this article

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s